Google Friend Connect – An Epic Failure

January 7, 2010 in facebook, google, tech, web | 30 Comments

I have been using Google’s friend connect feature for a long time on my blog. Though I have 66 followers for my blog through friend connect as on date, the kind of traffic generated to my blog through this is miserable! In the last 12 months, my site had over 1,96,600 visitors from various sources. Of these, only 52 visits source was Google Friend Connect Module. That is a mere ~0.026%. So, now my question is – should I continue using it or simply remove and continue with any other alternative? What is your experience, have you ever got a chance to measure the performance of ‘Friend Connect’ module by Google?

You may be wondering how I arrived at those numbers. The source for the mentioned stats is Google Analytics. Yes, If you have an account on Google Analytics for your blog/site, you would know all these metrics including number of visits, unique visitors, number of pages viewed per visit, demographics of visitors, break up of browsers/OS, Average time on site, content overview and many more. I really like the analytical info provided by Google. Going back to the point of discussion, has Google failed to create a strong social network through friend connect?

In contrast to Google’s friend connect, I recently added Facebook Fan widget on my blog. It has been less than 2 weeks since I added this widget and I already have 41 subscribers via Facebook. More over Facebook is providing a very clean way of publishing the content and to socialize with subscribers in a much better way. Even the traffic sourced from facebook has been a number of times better!

Those of you who use blogspot as your blogging platform, Google friend connect is made a default widget in the sidebar. Though Google is trying to promote this product the most through its free blogging solution, I doubt the kind of socialization element provided to increase the effectiveness. At least I was on the verge of removing it a couple of times, still continuing to see if it can get any better. I presume the time has come to retire Google ‘friend connect’ stuff on my blog. I am planning to do so because of a number of reasons. First one being the slowness to load this module. When a user makes a request to my blog, it does multiple DNS lookups to fetch the module. Secondly, kill some more time in fetching & loading the images etc.,

May be an integration of Google Friend Connect with its own product ‘Reader‘ might help to certain extent. But, looking at the kind of effectiveness Facebook has offered through its fan pages, I am jumping over there! It may also be possible that I haven’t got the trick of getting Google friend connect to work for me. If you have seen considerable success, please share the tips :) .

Since I am talking about socialization of blogs, let me take the liberty of showing some of the tools I have on my site. If you like any of the post, feel free to make use of any of the sharing options I have provided. Just below this article, you have options to share this article via ‘Yahoo! Buzz’, Facebook, Twitter, Email, Digg, stumbleupon and many more! Please do make use of these and share with others whenever you like a particular post. Oh yeah… you have an option to subscribe for email notification as well! look at the top of right sidebar, feel free to subscribe if you haven’t done that yet.

{ 28 comments… read them below or add one }

1 shraddha January 8, 2010 at 12:11 am

in my cirlce, google friend connect is considered important as its numbers add to your subscriber counts….

where as twitter or facebook fans are not added to that count on feedburner..

i was nominated to speak for a blogger conference…the details they wanted from me was subscribers, twitter followers , page rank, stats and technorati authority..

facebook is easy growth and my blog hit 140 fans in no time….
i know of a fellow blogger who hit 600 fans in a week! imagine!
somehow no one has asked me those numbers yet!
lets see!

i have not focussed on technorati at all and i have no idea how they calculate authority anymore….i need to work on that..

do you know..like facebook and goole friend connect..you can show faces of your twitter followers through a widget on your blog.. its called twitter fan..
i am using it to my new experimental blog…..
have a look!!!

Reply

2 Mohan January 8, 2010 at 9:06 am

As far as I look at this, it is only a boast factor to say that I have so many followers! nothing more advantageous than that.. True that facebook and twitter are dominating the blogosphere. I will see how twitter goes on your blog before implementing it on mine :)

Reply

3 Shrinidhi Hande January 8, 2010 at 1:40 am

I made an attempt to understand what are its advantages-then abandoned..

Reply

4 Mohan January 8, 2010 at 9:07 am

Don’t worry.. its not worth the time to spend on it anyways :)

Reply

5 lostworld January 8, 2010 at 8:55 am

To be honest, your post went over my head though I read it twice Mohan. But its not you. Its me. I don’t use of any of the technologies mentioned. Just login to blogspot & post. I follow blogs like yours because I store the links. Ya ya, I’m technologically illiterate basically .. !!!! :-D

Reply

6 Mohan January 8, 2010 at 9:11 am

Hey Ro, visit my home page. You will find both the google friend connect and facebook fan page. Those are the two widgets I am talking about in this post wrt the kind of traffic they drive to an individuals blog. Don’t panic, you will know about these over a period of time ;)

Reply

7 Aparna January 8, 2010 at 4:51 pm

I guess I have the same problems as listed above! :(
Though I considered myself tech-savvy, blog-lingo is too confusing for me!! I wish I had some genie to train me, and set my blog up! I could take it from there.. ;)

Reply

8 Mohan January 8, 2010 at 4:58 pm

Heheheee… don’t get confused… feel free to be my ‘mentee’ to get trained if you wish to ;)

Reply

9 Aparna January 11, 2010 at 11:37 am

Would love to!!! Will get in touch for sure…

Reply

10 Tavish January 8, 2010 at 10:06 am

I agree with you. Google friend connect isn’t the best way to build traffic…. i use blogspot as a platform and it comes in default with it… and honestly i never gave it much of an importance too… thanks for letting me know about google analytics… would love to try that out…

latest blog post: The Supreme court of media

Reply

11 Mohan January 8, 2010 at 4:27 pm

Thanks for your views. Sure, try out analytics, it is really nice and you get to know about your blog readers better :)

Reply

12 Parth J Dave January 8, 2010 at 11:20 am

Well, first of all you need to have Google Friend Connect on your home page and also preferably, in the sidebar which I can’t see right now.

One more reason you are having trouble with Google Friend Connect is because you have a self-hosted site. Basically, if you observe, all blogspot hosted blogs have this widget in-built so people can easily follow those blogs.. Here in your case, it’s a little tedious, I suppose..

..And, anyway, I agree with some of the above comments with the point that Google Friend Connect should not be used to measure traffic. There are other factors like RSS subscribers, e-mail subscribers, visitors from search engines and maybe even Facebook fans to take into consideration…

Well, that’s it..Sorry for such a long comment..I just wanted to express my views on this topic.. And, by the way, ALL THE BEST!

Reply

13 Mohan January 8, 2010 at 4:30 pm

Parth, it has been there and it exists even now on the home page. I haven’t put it in sidebar for my own reasons. I really fail to understand what makes the self hosted sites go against making an effective use! Irrespective of the host, the product should deliver what it is supposed to! I don’t think people feel any different on blogger as well. Thanks for your comment. I really appreciate it :)

Reply

14 Swaram January 8, 2010 at 1:19 pm

Interesting analysis .. I don’t use either though :P
Just comfortable posting n hopping arnd .. will bookmark this page for future reference :)

Reply

15 Mohan January 8, 2010 at 4:37 pm

You are already a celebrity in your territory :D , you don’t need such widgets for sure with so many fans of your blog (including me ;) )

Reply

16 SaurabhStar January 9, 2010 at 9:56 am

Rightly said. Google friend connect helps in nothing than just boasting that you have x number of followers through google friend connect. I like the term “fan” more than the term “followers”, while I am using none on my blogs. Quality readership is the real need of every blogger and Mohan, you got quality readers.

Reply

17 Mohan January 9, 2010 at 9:55 pm

Thanks Saurabh. Yes, the point i wanted to bring in is that, GFC is not really helping bloggers to connect and explore better traffic.

Reply

18 Roshmi Sinha January 9, 2010 at 5:54 pm

Interesting analysis… and you have awesome traffic on your blog. What with topics like tax planning, etc… it is obvious and expected :)

Reply

19 Mohan January 9, 2010 at 9:55 pm

All thanks to readers like you Roshmi :)

Reply

20 Haresh January 9, 2010 at 6:41 pm

Well, I’m using Google Friend Connect on my blog right now and am not going to remove from sidebar in near future for sure.

I don’t find it as useless as you probably find it. It does help to form small communities. Probably, it’s meant for small bloggers like us and not for you ;-)

Reply

21 Mohan January 9, 2010 at 9:56 pm

Good to hear that it is working for you.

Reply

22 lavi January 9, 2010 at 9:33 pm

My website (weebly) don’t allow google connect to integrate with it.. So facebook widget is the only source.. Since most of them use blogspot or wordpress GFC helps a lot I guess..
Also to add nthg like these (GFC or Facebook widgets) matters after a while.. If the writer/blog is writing well/popular ppl are gng to follow anyways..
Thats my opinion..
Last but not the least, Mr.Mohan, its very well written post..

Reply

23 Mohan January 9, 2010 at 9:58 pm

Sorry, i have little knowledge on weebly. That is true.. there are always better ways to keep updated about blogs with many other tools. Thank you :)

Reply

24 sm January 11, 2010 at 4:40 am

interesting post.
have to think on this more
thanks

Reply

25 Mohan January 11, 2010 at 9:13 am

Thanks, please share your thoughts after your analysis :)

Reply

26 Siddhu February 4, 2010 at 4:33 pm

I hate Google Friend Connect. But I keep it because most people use it, especially bloggers using blogspot…

Reply

27 vipul February 6, 2010 at 8:27 pm

I am agree with you.
Nice Post.

Reply

28 Mohan February 6, 2010 at 8:34 pm

Thanks Vipul… Welcome to my blog.

Reply

{ 2 trackbacks }

Google Friend Connect – An Epic Failure | Mohan's Blog | Google Friend Connect Blog
This thing is HUGE

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: